Skip to main content Scroll Top
The Tantura Massacre: A Drop in the Ocean
Font size

February 5, 2022

“You stole our tears, wolf. You kill me, steal my corpse, and sell it?” In these words, Mahmoud Darwish succinctly captured what the author describes as the nature of the brutal entity established through massacres, which has continued to loudly denounce what it calls terrorism, accusing the victim of rebelling against the conditions of her own killing when she resists being led to slaughter.

According to the article, this hybrid entity provided colonial powers with a means of controlling the region and its natural resources, while also making the Arabs pay the price for massacres committed by Europeans against Jewish communities there—culminating years of racism, discrimination, exclusion, and humiliation in the Holocaust. The author states that there is no need to diminish, minimize, or deny the Holocaust, and that doing so is not the subject here. Rather, the concern is with using the Holocaust as a cover or justification for the crimes and massacres attributed to the Israeli state, both past and subsequent.

Two important developments occupied a prominent place in regional and international news: the exposure of the Tantura massacre and the publication of Amnesty International’s report concerning the system of apartheid that it says Israel imposes on Palestinians. Around the same period, the United Nations General Assembly unanimously adopted a resolution on December 20 of the previous year concerning Holocaust denial and distortion, calling for education about the Holocaust and the annual observance of International Holocaust Remembrance Day on January 27.

However, according to the article, the media attention surrounding Holocaust denial and Holocaust Remembrance Day did not succeed in obscuring the issue of the Tantura massacre or the controversy generated by the documentary about it, which was screened at the Sundance Film Festival in the United States. The film attracted considerable attention because it was produced by an Israeli filmmaker and, according to the author, could not simply be dismissed as hostile propaganda.

The film was largely based on research conducted by an Israeli academic in the 1990s. The article claims that those opposed to the publication of the findings succeeded in forcing the researcher into silence and withdrawing his study. Let us return to the story from the beginning.

The Truth About the Massacre

Tantura was located south of Haifa. In 1945, it had a population of approximately 1,490 people. A paved road connected it to Haifa, and it had a railway, a harbor, and two schools—one for boys and another for girls. Its economy depended on fishing and agriculture, including citrus fruits, bananas, grains, and olives.

The massacre took place more than a month after the Deir Yassin massacre and one week after the declaration of what was called “independence.” According to the article, the decision to carry out the massacre was made on May 9, 1948, and the 33rd Battalion of the Alexandroni Brigade of the Haganah was assigned to carry it out on the night of May 22–23, 1948.

The village was reportedly selected because it was relatively easy to attack and because spreading terror among the beautiful Palestinian coastal villages would facilitate the removal of the Palestinian presence from an area that Zionist leaders wanted to be free of Arab inhabitants. According to the author, this could only be achieved through massacres and terror.

The attack began on the evening of May 22 from the sea. After several hours of continuous shelling, forces from the 33rd Battalion of the Alexandroni Brigade entered the village from several directions after the villagers refused to surrender.

The men of the village resisted until their ammunition was exhausted, and many were killed, including Qasim al-Dasuqi, Abd al-Rahman al-Dasuqi, Isa al-Hamdan and eleven members of his family, Hassan Abu Madi, Muhammad Shahada, Qasim al-Diqnash, Muhammad al-Awad, and Musa Abd al-Rahim.

After resistance was no longer possible, the massacre began. According to the article, men were executed in groups of six to ten. They were reportedly ordered to dig a pit before being killed and buried in it after their execution.

The article states that approximately 230 men were executed, while around 1,200 residents—women, children, and elderly people—fled or were expelled from the village. They were searched carefully and stripped of their possessions. The locations of the mass graves were subsequently altered, and the sites were later turned into parking areas for visitors to Dor Moshav beach.

Documentation

The article states that the Zionist authorities concealed what happened during the 1948 war and closed the files concerning massacres and what it describes as deliberate and systematic ethnic cleansing.

However, a number of Israeli historians known as the “New Historians” began examining the archives after the release of archival material was permitted approximately forty years after the establishment of Israel, in 1988. Some of these academics had studied in the West and began examining and publishing portions of the archives for various reasons. The article names Benny Morris, Avi Shlaim, and Tom Segev, as well as Ilan Pappé, whom it describes as belonging to the Israeli left and fundamentally opposed to Zionism.

According to the article, the Israeli historian who documented the Tantura massacre was Theodore Katz, a student of Ilan Pappé and a graduate student in the Department of Middle Eastern History at the University of Haifa. He submitted a master’s thesis entitled “The Exodus of Arabs from Villages at the Foot of Mount Carmel,” in which he documented the massacre allegedly carried out by Israeli soldiers in Tantura in May 1948 after the village had surrendered.

Katz documented the events using the methodology of oral history, collecting testimonies from witnesses. He interviewed twenty Palestinians from Tantura and twenty Israeli soldiers from the Haganah forces who had participated in or witnessed the events.

He met surviving Palestinians in areas near the former village and asked them about what had happened in the Arab villages. According to the article, he noticed that the phrase “a great massacre” repeatedly arose whenever Tantura was mentioned.

Katz is quoted as saying that he once met a man in his nineties who told him about the massacre that had taken place there. To verify the account, he began investigating the village and eventually reached what he described as a painful conclusion: that Tantura had witnessed one of the largest massacres suffered by Palestinians in 1948, when the Alexandroni unit allegedly killed 230 Palestinians.

Katz’s master’s thesis, completed in the 1990s, argued that the Israeli army—which had been formed from Haganah forces following the establishment of the state—had killed unarmed Palestinians in Tantura outside the context of combat, and that what occurred constituted a massacre on a large scale.

According to the article, the village fell to Israeli forces, after which soldiers engaged in a bloody pursuit through the streets and subsequently opened concentrated fire on residents. The article places the number of victims at approximately 230, allegedly buried in mass graves around the village. These sites were later turned into a parking area serving the Dor settlement’s beach on the Mediterranean coast south of Haifa.

Katz’s thesis was initially well received and received the highest grades from professors at the University of Haifa. It later became the subject of widespread national controversy after reaching the Israeli media in 2000.

Veterans of the Alexandroni Brigade, which the article identifies as responsible for the Tantura massacre, filed a lawsuit against Katz accusing him of defamation. Katz subsequently apologized and withdrew his conclusions. The article notes that he now describes this as “one of the biggest mistakes” of his life.

The Documentary Film

The Tantura massacre was brought back into public attention by the documentary film Tantura, directed and produced by Alon Schwarz. The film addresses the massacre allegedly carried out by Israeli forces in 1948 and was screened at the Sundance Film Festival in the United States, one of the world’s major documentary film festivals.

The massacre also received renewed attention in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz around the time of the film’s release.

The film includes testimonies from Israeli soldiers who say that they participated in the massacre. According to the article, these testimonies provide further evidence that the massacres, destruction, and displacement associated with 1948 remain an unresolved historical issue.

In addition to the testimonies, the film presents the views of historians and experts. One of them proposes that changes in the level of the ground before and after the battle may indicate human intervention in the soil, potentially suggesting that mass graves were dug at the site.

The film concludes that Palestinians may have been buried beneath what is now a parking lot beside Tantura beach, which is heavily visited today. The village of Tantura no longer exists; instead, the tourist settlement of Dor was established on its ruins, and its beaches were subsequently declared nature reserves.

Schwarz says that investigating the events of Tantura involved “personal psychological risks.” He adds that he had believed he understood his historical reality but had actually grown up on a myth. He argues that telling ourselves a story that there was no people here before us “will not be helpful,” describing it as a “foundational myth of the nation” and saying that Israeli society needs “to be truthful and mature.”

A Right That Refuses to Be Forgotten

Following the screening of Tantura, which once again brought the massacre into the spotlight, and following new information concerning the alleged mass graves, relatives of victims and survivors who had sought refuge in al-Fureidis reportedly gathered on Saturday, January 29.

In the presence of activists, they discussed declaring the mass-grave sites sacred places after examining and identifying them on the basis of survivors’ testimonies and with the assistance of experts and specialists.

The meeting resulted in the establishment of a popular committee representing the families of the massacre’s victims. Its purpose was to pursue the issue of the mass graves and begin practical steps toward achieving the families’ demands: requiring the Israeli authorities to acknowledge the crime, granting the victims’ families the right to know where the victims were buried, ending what the committee considers violations of the sanctity of Tantura’s historic cemetery and mass graves by the settlements of Dor and Nahsholim, and protecting and maintaining the graves in accordance with Islamic law.

The article concludes with a condemnation of the Israeli state and its reception in Arab capitals, arguing that an entity established, in the author’s view, through massacres, genocide, and ethnic cleansing is nevertheless welcomed as a savior, partner, and ally.

Originally published in Al-Quds Al-Arabi

Source: Palestinian Forum

Add Comment

Related Posts
Most Viewed